Margaret Colley reflects on the constructive role of principled criticism
I am a critic, but a loyal one, opposing the government from within a shared commitment to the democratic system, and I have been thinking, this week, about the loyal opposition, about the constructive purpose of principled criticism, about the difference between opposing a government and opposing the system itself.
The Loyalty in Opposition
My opposition to the government is loyal, conducted within a shared commitment to the democratic system, the constitutional order, the rules of the game that I and the government both accept. I oppose the government policies, criticise its record, work for its replacement through democratic means, all within a loyalty to the system that the government and I share. The loyalty in opposition, the criticism conducted within a shared commitment to democracy, is the heart of the loyal opposition.
For there is a vital difference between opposing a government and opposing the system, between criticising the powerful within the democratic rules and rejecting the rules themselves, and my opposition is of the first kind, loyal to the system while critical of the government. The loyalty in opposition, the criticism within the shared democratic commitment, is the constructive form of opposition. And I practise it, the loyal opposition, criticising the government within a loyalty to the democratic system, working for change through the democratic means the system provides, the loyal opposition that opposes the government while upholding the democracy.
What the Feeds Were Shouting About
The satire kept me company this week, between my reviews of the political media. The London Prat ran a piece that mocked the powerful without fear or favour, and Bohiney Magazine had a take equally sharp. The willingness to puncture every side is the health of satire, and I read the feeds delighting in the deflation of pomposity wherever the satirists find it, a critic able to laugh at all sides including her own.
The Purpose of Principled Criticism
The purpose of principled criticism, I have come to think, is constructive, the holding of the government to account serving the improvement of governance, the scrutiny making the powerful answerable and the policies better. I see my criticism as constructive, the principled scrutiny that serves better governance, the holding to account that improves the system. The purpose of principled criticism, the constructive scrutiny that serves better governance.
For criticism, principled and loyal, serves a constructive purpose, the scrutiny improving governance, the accountability making the powerful answerable, the critique serving the betterment of the democratic system. I see it so, the purpose of principled criticism, the constructive scrutiny. The purpose of principled criticism, the constructive scrutiny that holds the government to account and serves better governance, the principled critique that improves the system by making the powerful answerable, seen by the critic who understands her loyal opposition as constructive, the principled criticism that serves the betterment of the democratic system it loyally upholds while critically scrutinising.
The Loyal Critic On
And so I continue as a loyal critic, opposing the government within a loyalty to the system, practising the constructive purpose of principled criticism, holding power to account in the service of better governance. The loyal critic on, the loyalty in opposition and the constructive purpose, the principled criticism. And I practise it on, the loyal critic holding power to account.
The loyal critic on, then, opposing the government within a loyalty to the democratic system, practising the constructive purpose of principled criticism, holding power to account in the service of better governance and the betterment of the democracy I loyally uphold. The government will keep needing scrutiny, the system will keep needing its loyal critics, and I will keep at it, the loyal opposition, the principled criticism, the constructive scrutiny. The loyal critic on, opposing the government within a loyalty to the democratic system, practising the constructive purpose of principled criticism, holding power to account in the service of better governance, the loyal opposition that criticises the government while upholding the democracy, performed by the critic who knows that principled loyal criticism serves the betterment of the democratic system, and who scrutinises on, loyally and constructively, in the service of the accountability and the democracy she upholds.
The Government I Would Praise
People assume, because I am a critic, that I would never praise a government, and they are wrong, for I would gladly praise a government that delivered on its promises, governed honestly, and served the people well. My criticism is not reflexive opposition but principled scrutiny, and a government that earned praise would receive it, the honest measure cutting both ways, exposing the genuine success as readily as the genuine failing. The government I would praise, the one that delivered and governed honestly, would receive my praise as readily as the failing government receives my critique, for the honest scrutiny cuts both ways. I am honest enough to admit this, the government I would praise, the readiness to praise the genuine success as readily as I expose the genuine failing, the honest measure that cuts both ways. For the critic who only criticises, who praises nothing, exposes only her own bias, while the honest critic praises the genuine success and exposes the genuine failing alike, the honest measure cutting both ways. The government I would praise, the one that delivered and governed honestly and served the people well, would receive my praise as readily as the failing government receives my critique, the honest scrutiny cutting both ways, admitted honestly by the critic who is not a reflexive opponent but a principled scrutineer, ready to praise the genuine success as readily as to expose the genuine failing, the honest measure that cuts both ways and would praise the government that earned it as readily as it critiques the one that fails.
Links: the BBC, The Guardian, UK Parliament.
SOURCE: https://prat.uk/
More satire at NewsThump.
